Sunday, September 28, 2008

OGS Statement of Interest

My name is Ada Chidichimo Jeffrey and I am enrolled in a 2 year Master’s program at the University of Toronto in order to have sufficient time to complete my research project which includes large numbers of interviews as well as data analysis. I would like to research the role that religious institutions play in the integration of immigrants into Canada. Specifically the questions I would to address are as follows: Do religious institutions in Canada provide resources for integration that immigrants might not otherwise have access to as readily? Or, do religious institutions in Canada actually work against the process of integration by encouraging immigrants to identify themselves first as members of a particular community, and secondly, as Canadians?
Traditionally, scholarship on religion and immigration has maintained that religious institutions play a positive role in the integration of immigrants. They serve as community centres which put recent immigrants in touch with resources for housing, employment and social services while offering a support network of people with similar language and culture. Nancy Foner and Richard Alba in their article “Immigrant Religion: Bridge or Barrier to Integration?” (2008) state that this is primarily the case for immigrants integrating into the United States. Alternatively, some of the literature on the subject takes the opposite view, that religion and religious institutions are a barrier to integration. These scholars are mostly writing with regards to the Western European case wherein the government is typically more secular, and primary religion of immigrants is Islam. These authors, such as Buijs and Rath (2002) suggest that religious institutions (specifically Islamic religious Institutions) encourage “cultural isolationism”, and can lead to acts of violence and terrorism.
While much literature has been written about the role of religion on immigration in the United States and Western Europe, there has not been much work on the topic in Canada. The research being undertaken by Prof. Jeffrey Reitz at the University of Toronto is unique in this regard because it examines the Canadian experience of immigration with recourse to role of religion (Reitz 2008). I believe I am well situated to benefit from and hopefully contribute to his research due to my experience in the field of comparative religion and my involvement in his
collaborative program Ethnicity and Pluralism Studies. This program, when combined with my courses in the Study of Religion will enable me to address issues of race, gender and ethnicity in collaboration with my previous background in religious studies. Additionally, my fluency in both French and Spanish will allow me to access materials in other languages, including research done on the Quebec situation.
In order to answer the aforementioned questions I will use both quantitative and qualitative sources in my methodology, while also referring to some background literature in order to contextualize my findings. Quantitatively, I shall use data from the 2002 Ethnic Diversity Survey in order to provide background on the number of immigrants who declare a strong religious affiliation, and of whom, the percentage who feel accepted by Canadian society. Also Canadian census data will provide information on the degree to which these immigrants are structurally integrated into Canadian society vis-à-vis employment, education and housing levels. To obtain qualitative field data, I shall conduct interviews with several prominent religious institutions in the GTA whose congregation is primarily new Canadians. Some of these institutions include: The New Life Church on Queen St. E, and the Jafari Mosque. Finally, authors such as Jeffrey Reitz, Nancy Foner and Richard Alba, and Charles Hirschman provide relevant, contemporary articles that I can use to situate my own findings.
I am confident that my previous training, and skill-set, when combined with the resources of the University of Toronto, will allow me to undertake original research on the role of religious institutions on the integration of immigrants which will ultimately benefit Canada in the area of immigration policy and social service improvements. I hope to provide an answer to the question: Should Canada be supporting religious institutions as an intermediary way of providing access to services to new immigrants, or should Canada attempt to provide these services itself?



Works Cited
Jeffrey G. Reitz, Rupa Banerjee, Mai Phan, and Jordan Thompson. "Race, Religion, and the Social Integration of New Immigrant Minorities in Canada," September 2008;

Foner, Nancy and Richard Alba. “Immigrant Religion: Bridge or Barrier to Inclusion?” International Migration Review. 42.2 (Summer 2008): 360-392.

Hirschman, Charles. “The Role of Religion in the Origins and Adaptations of Immigrant Groups in the United States.” International Migration Review. 38.3 (Fall 2004): 1206-1233.

Buijs, F. J., and J. Rath. “Muslims in Europe: The State of Research.” IMISCOE Working Paper. (2006).

5 comments:

Nathalie LaCoste said...

Hey Ada,

Great work on your proposal. I liked the way you presented the gap (religion on the integration of immigrants into Canada) at the beginning. It amazed me that this type of research had not yet been done in Canada and it definitely caught my attention.

I am wondering if you need to mention all the background experience that you wrote about. While I think it is great to mention and show your preparation, you wrote a lot about it and I am wondering if perhaps the effect is lost in the midst of it all. This is just something to think about.

Your conclusion was great! Very well written.

Anonymous said...

Hi Ada,

Before I comment, just wanted to ask you if this is perhaps a bit long? The OGS website states that these proposals must be 1 page, Arial font, size 12, ¾ inch margins. Overall I think this is well written and an interesting subject, but you may want to be a little bit more specific.

For example, in the first paragraph you say “there has not been much work on the topic in Canada”. You may want to demonstrate more clearly where the “gap” in the existing research lies.

In the third paragraph when you make the claim that secular societies are potentially more hostile to religious immigrants in Western Europe and that Christianity in the US tends to produce a different effect, mention an author or two to support this. It could be argued that the Christian presence in the US makes for a less accommodating environment for immigrants of different faiths. To defend your claim I think you should cite a source or two.

Also, I’m not quite clear on your plan of action. What sort of case studies are you using and from which institutions are you planning to draw? You explained what the Ethnic Diversity Survey accomplishes but there is no indication in the paragraph, that you will be using this survey. Are you going to focus on a particular community?

The last paragraph on your preparation is strong but tends to overshadow the rest of the proposal and I would try to condense it if I were you. The last six lines might serve better as a concluding paragraph- maybe you can separate them from the paragraph they are in now as it is mostly about your experience and doesn’t quite connect to these six lines.

Just some thoughts…Best of luck!

Ada Chidichimo Jeffrey said...

Hey guys, thanks for your comments, I have done a lot of subsequent editing, and reposted. I was unclear on the requirements at first, but now I get that I can have a 1 page statement of interest, 1 page of plan of study. I don't want to force you guys to read any more though, so if you've already commented, no worries!

Mike Jones said...

I commented on the other one, but thought it was your proposal since i didn't see this. I'll look at this one in a bit

smithsan said...

Studying the holy books of the Abrahamic faiths would be a good method in order to get a deeper understanding of Judaism, Christianity.
---------
smithsan
smm